Now what to do. My first time anal was actually I Think You Have The Wrong Hole accident. Login Register. I think that's what happend to me. I know its supposed to come out of the hole before that, but its not. If you want to get notified by every reply to your post, please register. Swallow pills in the wrong hole. A Doctor will be with you shortly. No matter which opening you wanted your boyfriend's penis to enter, there really is no way for me, or anyone, to tell you whether it ended up in your vagina or your anus unless they Rinrin Boys Gif watching you at the time. Instant Access to Doctors.